| 1975 | Mr. H. Lyman Stebbins † | 
		
			| 1976 | Charles E. Rice, J.D. † | 
		
			| 1977 | Rev. Christopher J. O’Toole, C.S.C. † | 
		
			| 1978 | Most Rev. Jerome J. Hastrich, D.D. † | 
		
			| 1979 | Most Rev. Norman F. McFarland, D.D., J.C.D. † | 
		
			| 1980 | Colin G. Clark, Ph.D. † | 
		
			| 1981 | Rev. John A. Hardon, S.J. † | 
		
			| 1982 | St. Teresa of Calcutta, M.C. † | 
		
			| 1985 | Mr. Carl N. Karcher † Ralph M. McInerny, Ph.D. †
 | 
		
			| 1986 | Rev. Thomas A. McGovern, S.J. † (In Memoriam) Norman P. De Silva, Ph.D. † (In Memoriam)
 | 
		
			| 1987 | Rev. Monsignor Vincent I. Carroll † | 
		
			| 1989 | John Cardinal O’Connor † | 
		
			| 1990 | Herbert Ratner, M.D. † | 
		
			| 1991 | Sr. Eileen MacDonald, I.H.M. † (In Memoriam) | 
		
			| 1993 | Sir Daniel J. Donohue † | 
		
			| 1995 | Most Rev. Renato R. Martino | 
		
			| 1996 | Ronald P. McArthur, Ph.D. † | 
		
			| 1997 
 | Right Rev. Ladislas K. Parker, O.Praem., S.T.D. † The Honorable William P. Clark, J.D. †
 | 
		
			| 1998 | Anthony Cardinal Bevilacqua †Rev. Thomas Conn, S.J. † (In Memoriam)
 | 
		
			| 1999 | Jan Cardinal Schotte † | 
		
			| 2000 | The Honorable Jeremiah A. Denton, Jr. † | 
		
			| 2001 | Francis Cardinal George, O.M.I. † | 
		
			| 2002 | Christoph Cardinal Schönborn, O.P. | 
		
			| 2003 | J. Francis Cardinal Stafford | 
		
			| 2004 | Francis Cardinal Arinze | 
		
			| 2005 | Avery Cardinal Dulles, S.J. † | 
		
			| 2006 | Most Rev. Celestino Migliori | 
		
			| 2007 | Albert Malcolm Cardinal Ranjith | 
		
			| 2008 | George Cardinal Pell | 
		
			| 2009 | Dr. Thomas E. Dillon † (In Memoriam) Marc Cardinal Ouellet
 | 
		
			| 2010 | Raymond Cardinal Burke, D.D., J.C.D. | 
		
			| 2011 | The Most Rev. José H. Gomez, S.T.D. Mr. Marcus R. Berquist † (In Memoriam)
 | 
		
			| 2012 | Peter L. DelucaJohn W. Neumayr, Ph.D. †
 Mother Mary Assumpta Long, O.P.
 | 
		
			| 2013 | Rev. Cornelius M. Buckley, S.J. Daniel Cardinal DiNardo
 | 
		
			| 2014 | Edwin Cardinal O’Brien | 
		
			| 2015 | Sr. Regina Marie Gorman, O.C.D. | 
		
			| 2016 | The Most Rev. Salvatore J. Cordileone Gerhard Cardinal Müller
 | 
		
			| 2017 | Mother Agnes Mary Donovan, S.V. | 
		
			| 2018 | The Most Rev. Robert C. Morlino † | 
		
			| 2019 | The Most Rev. Robert E. Barron | 
		
			| 2021 | The Most. Rev. Thomas J. Paprocki | 
		
			| 2022 | Carl A. AndersonMichael F. McLean, Ph.D.
 Most Rev. Robert J. McManus, S.T.D.
 | 
		
			| 2023 | The Most Rev. James D. Conley, D.D., S.T.L. |